Miss Israel Responds to ‘Dirty Look’ Accusation Towards Miss Palestine
Published on: November 12, 2025
A Viral Moment Sparks Outrage
At the recent Miss Universe 2025 event held in Thailand, a brief moment captured on camera has led to significant online backlash. Miss Israel, Melanie Shiraz, is facing allegations of giving Miss Palestine, Nadeen Ayoub, a “dirty look” during the pageant, igniting a flurry of social media reactions.
Social Media Reactions and Accusations
The controversy erupted after a video clip surfaced showing Melanie momentarily glancing at Nadeen while the contestants were on stage. Many viewers interpreted this glance as a “jealous” or “dirty” look, leading to widespread criticism across various platforms.
Commenters inundated Melanie’s social media with messages such as “Free Palestine,” with some users going so far as to label her “Miss Genocide,” a reference to ongoing military operations in Gaza.
Melanie Shiraz’s Response
In light of the accusations, Melanie Shiraz took to Instagram to clarify her actions. In a comment reported by Daily Mail, she firmly denied the allegations, stating, “It’s very clear that I was simply looking toward other contestants as they came on stage.” She emphasized the importance of not misrepresenting moments and urged people to consider the impact of their words before allowing such narratives to gain traction.
A Historic Competition
This year’s Miss Universe pageant is notably historic as it features Nadeen Ayoub, marking her as the first-ever Miss Palestine to compete on this global stage. In her own social media statement, Ayoub expressed pride in representing her homeland, highlighting the resilience and hope of Palestinian women and children.
Wider Context of Tension at Miss Universe
The controversy surrounding the interactions between the contestants isn’t the only issue at the Miss Universe event. Recently, several contestants staged a walkout to protest the treatment of Miss Mexico, Fatima Bosch, by a pageant official during a pre-pageant ceremony. This incident has added to the scrutiny facing the competition and the overall treatment of contestants.
An Official Apology
Following the backlash against the official’s harsh treatment of Miss Mexico, the individual publicly apologized in a press conference, visibly emotional as they addressed the situation. This incident underscores the growing awareness and activism taking place within the beauty pageant landscape.
Looking Ahead
As the Miss Universe 2025 event continues to unfold, all eyes are on how these situations will be resolved and what they mean for the future of the pageant. The dynamics of representation and personal interactions among contestants highlight a broader conversation about cultural sensitivity and mutual respect in international platforms.
